Conceptualism and eliteism

-


Dear reader,



There is currently a debate taking place over on thinkingardens.co.uk regarding the 'New' Perennial Planting 'Elite' and whether us mere mortals with small 'domestic' gardens have been influenced by them or indeed have tried to replicate them.


Mixed perennials - calamagrostis bought at Noel's garden




I have to take issue with Noel Kingsbury and his attitude to conceptual art in his blogpost - there is far more to the work of Tracey Emin than her bed. There is a need it seems for us humans to create some kind of hierarchy - we find it so so difficult to accommodate the vast range of tastes displayed by our fellow humans. I have to admit that I struggle to find beauty in some gardens, but I try. In much the same way I try to understand and appreciate the art of both amateur and professional artists. But inevitably there will always be elitism because whole industries depend upon our insecurities and need to fit in.




Dense planting - as dense as the planter


The disappearing 'lawn'

I have been influenced by NP gardens mainly because I have had the privilege to visit the gardens of the 'Elite' and have at times stuck my ignorant head out and joined in the debates about gardens and garden making. I'm not a great fan of Piet Oudolf's Hauser&Wirth garden in Somerset. It is all a bit one dimensional in terms of height - but I did like the beauty of the decaying stems and heads of the perennials (I preferred the work of conceptual artist and late friend of Emin - Louise Bourgeois that was on magnificent display within the gallery at the time of my visit.) I have visited Noel's last garden in Herefordshire which I found helpful in that it clarified what I was trying to achieve in my small cloistered garden on the side of a hill near the Brecon Beacons. My garden has wet areas and small 'wild' areas influenced by the wet areas of his garden. I'm trying to encourage biodiversity in a small way.

Marc Owen marcsgardens.blogspot.com suggests in his blog that the ordinary garden maker has not taken up the ideas of perennial planting- perhaps there are more of us out there experimenting with perennials than either he or Noel realises ?

The ecological view of planting has mainly focused on bees and pollinators - and I agree with Noel that a garden has to do much more than just support the pollinators but it is a welcome start.

There is an interesting project under way at the National Botanic Garden of Wales called Growing the Future - they aim to encourage ordinary folk to garden in more ecologically friendly ways - find out more at botanicgarden.wales/science/growing-the-future


National Botanic Garden of Wales trial pollinator seed mix beds


I wish I was more articulate !


Paul.

Comments

  1. Diana Studer9 September 2018 at 20:50

    With Cape Town's drought we gardeners are certainly focused on perennials. But then I have always preferred shrubs, trees. Anything but fiddly fussy annuals.

    ReplyDelete
  2. JohnK10 September 2018 at 10:11

    Au contraire, you are very articulate. I think it's a matter of, in a way, extremes. In art, at one end of the line you have the Emins and others who seek to convey something in their art which is often appreciated only by those who are themselves artists whilst others "ooh and aah" without really appreciating anything other than the visual image they are looking at; at the other end, there are those who paint things which we ordinary people like to look at again and again, appreciating the view of a garden or the detail of a butterfly, for example.

    In gardening (or horticulture) we have the same two ends. The style of Piet or Noel needs space to be really effective and there are those who can appreciate that style whilst others (you know, the type who a mutual friend refers to as the "hoi polloi" go ooh and aah at without necessarily appreciating what's behind the planting. Meanwhile we, in our smaller gardens, cannot hope to achieve the same effect; rather we work with the space we have and make it our own. We, perhaps, appreciate more the beauty of a single plant in "close up" rather than the impact of a large drift of the same stuff.

    I get far more from visiting a small garden open for the NGS, with its intimacy, than from visiting large estates. So I guess I would prefer the garden of a Steer to that of an Oudolf. One being made with love and the other with money and clinical precision.

    ReplyDelete
  3. William Martins 'Wigandia'10 December 2021 at 06:27

    Hear, hear!
    "I get far more from visiting a small garden open for the NGS, with its intimacy, than from visiting large estates. So I guess I would prefer the garden of a Steer to that of an Oudolf. One being made with love and the other with money and clinical precision."
    All hail Margery Fish!
    William Billy Martin. (primal_distraction) Kampuchea.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Pity the cabbage white

-
Image
Dear Monty, Having seen you protect your newly planted cabbages from cabbage white butterflies - it made me realise that I haven't seen many this year. Despite warmth yesterday - a brief interlude with blue sky and a light wind there was a dearth of butterflies in the coal tip garden. There were honey bees, bumble bees, wasps, hover flies, a gangly legged wasp, one hedge brown, one speckled wood and a common blue - that is all. Oh and a frog sheltering in the shady hosta and a silent peregrine falcon swooping overhead. What has happened to all the insects ? What has happened to all the aphids this year ? Is it just me that is missing them ? I have seen no ladybirds or ladybird larvae - because there have been so few aphids - was it the birds that have snaffled them ? I worry about the lack of insect numbers. We walked through a wild meadow full of meadow cranesbill and meadowsweet with the purple haze of knapweed in the grasses and yet there were one or two meadow br...
Read more

Letter to Monty Don 48

-
Image
Dear Monty, I know that despite these rambles being addressed to you, they never reach your eyes or heart, but this question is most certainly directed to you : Can nature be ugly ? I am pondering this question sitting in my cupboard of a 'studio' where I am putting the finishing touches to paintings of  British native orchids, pollinators and butterflies for an exhibition next weekend. Now I believe that you understand perfectly well the response you may get when you make statements on GW - including the one about spent buddleja flowers being 'ugly'. I too have always deadheaded my buddleja for the same reason, and as you said to promote new flower spikes. But this ugliness is an intrinsic part of nature - it sets seed to create the next generation, the flowers last but for a few days. Is this ugliness a kind of acknowledgement of the frailty of 'beauty' .... and the cutting off and tidying away a kind of denial ? ( Perhaps I think too much.) I ...
Read more

Monty, where does the road take us ?

-
Image
Monty, I see you have returned to France. Your film reminded me of my visits to Paris as an art student between 1981-83. It is a city that cannot fail to make an impression with its wide open streets, avenues of trees, the river and public gardens. I particularly remember Versailles with its long canal. At that time I was not aware of having a particular interest in gardens, but the gardens at Versailles were astonishing. I saw them in early morning light, when there were not that many people there. I also remember being intrigued by the garden at the Musee Rodin. Strangely for an art student, it was not the sculpture that caught my attention but the garden with pyramid shaped topiary. Perhaps what I was responding to was the sense of order, balance and harmony. It almost feels as though I was meant to visit, and that the encounters I had which were sensually intense, were pre-ordained. There is one incident, which has great significance only to me perhaps, but which was of ...
Read more